Should I Play I Should Have Known That?

Is I Should Have Known That fun to play?
I Should Have Known That

Players: 2 – 99 players | Game Duration 15 – 45 mins |
Min. Age 14+ | Game complexity: EASY Genre: Trivia
Solo game mode: No | Co-op: No |
Online Version: No

Buy on Amazon

Hate Rulebooks? Check out our condensed How to Play I Should Have Known That Rules Guide

What is I Should Have Known That about?

“I Should Have Known That!” is a trivia game that challenges players with questions about everyday knowledge and common facts. 

Summary of Gameplay

The gameplay of “I Should Have Known That!” is straightforward and easy to pick up, even for those new to trivia games. Here’s a quick rundown:

  1. Setup: The game consists of a deck of question cards. Each card has four questions, and the answers are written on the back.
  2. Turns: Players take turns reading a question to the player on their left. If the questioned player answers correctly, they simply avoid losing points. If they answer incorrectly or cannot answer, they lose points.
  3. Scoring: Unlike standard trivia games, in “I Should Have Known That!” you lose points for wrong answers. 
  4. Winning: The game continues until a predetermined number of questions have been asked or a set time limit is reached. The player with the fewest points (i.e., the least wrong answers) at the end of the game wins.

Game Mechanics

“I Should Have Known That!” employs several unique mechanics that make it stand out from other trivia games:

  • Negative Scoring: Players start with zero points and lose points for incorrect answers. This twist adds a layer of strategy, as players must decide whether to risk answering a question or to pass.
  • Variety of Questions: The questions cover a wide range of topics, from history and geography to pop culture and everyday trivia.
  • Simple Rules: The game is designed to be easy to learn and quick to play, making it accessible to players of all ages and experience levels.

Who is likely to find I Should Have Known That fun?

“I Should Have Known That!” is perfect for a wide range of audiences:

  • Trivia Enthusiasts: Those who love testing their knowledge and learning new facts will find this game particularly enjoyable.
  • Families: The game is suitable for ages 14 and up, making it a great option for family game nights.
  • Casual Gamers: With its simple rules and quick setup, the game is ideal for casual gamers looking for something fun and engaging without a steep learning curve.
  • Party Game Fans: The game’s entertaining questions and the fun of seeing who knows (or doesn’t know) common facts make it a hit at parties and social gatherings.

What are I Should Have Know That players saying about the game?

  • Wide Range of Topics: Questions cover diverse subjects such as history, pop culture, science, and literature.
  • Engaging Gameplay: The game encourages lively discussions, quick thinking, and friendly competition among players.
  • Accessibility: Simple rules and focus on common knowledge make it easy for players of all ages and backgrounds to enjoy.


  • Educational and Fun: Balances fun and learning, with questions that spark curiosity and deeper discussions.
  • Versatile Use: Portable and suitable for various settings, including car trips, picnics, and beach outings.
  • Interactive and Inclusive: Promotes engagement and interaction among players, enhancing the overall gaming experience.

Common Feedback:

  • Positive Experiences: Many players appreciated the game’s ability to challenge their knowledge without being overly difficult.
  • Minor Criticisms: Some noted the inconsistency in question difficulty and the unusual scoring system, though these did not significantly detract from the fun.
Find out about I Should Have Known That


Condensed How to Play I Should Have Known That Rules Guide for rulebook haters

I Should Have Known That Videos

User Submitted Videos

No Entries Found

Submit your videos

User Board Game Videos

Do you have a video on Youtube or Vimeo about this game to share? Login to post.

Join our community and post it on this page.

Your Mastodon Instance
Share to...